A beer that calls itself Champagne? I had to take a closer look
When I read the news that Canada's Supreme Court had rejected an appeal from the Comité Interprofessionnel du Vin de Champagne, I had to look twice. Miller High Life, a cheap beer from the US, is still allowed to advertise in Canada with the slogan "The Champagne of Beers." As someone who spends a lot of my free time on Champagne and tends to get a bit sensitive when the name "Champagne" is used for anything other than the drink from the region of the same name, that was a bit of a sting at first.
But on closer reading, the whole thing turns out to be more complicated, and honestly more interesting, than the headline suggests.
What this case was actually about
This is the point I think matters, and the one a lot of people seem to miss when skimming the news: the court didn't rule on whether a beer is allowed to call itself "Champagne" at all. The question was a much more technical one, namely whether Coors (or previously Miller) could keep its Canadian trademark registrations even though the slogan hadn't been actively used there since around 2012. Under Canadian trademark law, marks can be struck from the register if they haven't been used in commerce for an extended period. Coors argued that it had been preparing for a market launch and was tied up with regulatory approvals. The Canadian trademark office accepted that, the Federal Court upheld it, the Federal Court of Appeal did too, and now the Supreme Court declined to even hear the case.
To me, that makes a big difference. This wasn't about whether the name is justified, it was only about whether an administrative procedure for removing a trademark had been carried out correctly. That's a procedural win for Molson Coors, not a substantive one.
Why the Champagne region is fighting this at all
Here's what I learned while reading up on this: the term "Champagne" is a protected designation of origin in the EU and in many other countries. That means only sparkling wine from the defined region in France, produced according to the rules that apply there, is allowed to carry that name. The Comité Champagne defends this protection very consistently, and I think that's fundamentally the right approach. If the name could be used freely for shampoo, perfume, or beer, its meaning would erode over time. That's exactly why, in 2023, over 2,000 cans of Miller High Life on their way to Germany were destroyed in Antwerp. So within Europe, the protection works. In Canada, the legal situation is apparently different, at least when it comes to this specific trademark.
Does this change anything about what Champagne means?
In my opinion, no. The Comité Champagne itself stressed that this ruling doesn't call the validity or distinctiveness of the Appellation into question, neither in Canada nor anywhere else. I agree. An old US advertising slogan that first appeared back in 1906 as "The Champagne of Bottle Beers" and was shortened in 1969 has grown out of its own history, and to me it comes across more as a curiosity from an era when "Champagne" was used as shorthand for "the best of its kind," without anyone seriously thinking they were actually drinking Champagne. A bit like people used to talk about the "Rolls-Royce of vacuum cleaners."
Still, it leaves a slightly uneasy feeling. Precisely because Champagne carries so much craftsmanship, time, and Terroir within it, I find it a shame when the name ends up on a beer coaster, even if it's just a marketing phrase.
What I take away from this as a fellow Champagne fan
What this case shows me above all is how differently trademark protection and protection of origin work across different legal systems. In Europe, the term Champagne is extremely well protected. In North America, the situation has grown historically and is, in some ways, contradictory. None of this changes how I personally approach the topic. When I open a bottle, what interests me is the origin, the grower, the vintage, the Dosage, not a decades-old advertising slogan from an American brewery.
In the end, for me it comes down to a simple truth: there's only one Champagne, and it's definitely not in a beer can.